By The Sugar Daddy has more than 300 cookie cutters in the collection with more being added every week. The best way to search the below is to access it via a pc and hit Cntrl+F and enter a keyword that's relevant for your theme. 

​

If you're unsure of what the cutter may look like, or want to see examples, just message us via instagram, Facebook, email or the website and we can provide pics! 

​

THEME SETS 

Barbie (Barbie head, dress, high heels, Barbie word/sign, sunglasses)  

Beach theme (beach ball, sunglasses, surf board, bucket and spades)  

Bluey (Bluey, Bingo, Bluey word/sign, Dad Bandit, Mum Chilli)  
Christmas theme – Santa, sleigh, bells, stocking, reindeer, Christmas tree, candy cane, holly, gift box,  wreath

Dinosaurs (t-rex, stegosaurus, pterodactyl, triceratops, brachiosaurus, dino egg)  

Easter themed cookies – bunny face, bunny in potplant, bunny in the back of old school ute truck, stained glass window with three crosses, stained glass window with one cross and love hearts, easter egg, ‘hoppy easter’ with bunny ears, bunny holding easter egg, praying hands, ‘Have a blessed Easter’ message for round cookie  

Fairy garden (fairy swinging in tree, fairy, lady bug, mushroom, butterfly)  

Floral/flowers (rose, daisy, sunflower, generic flower, daffodil)  

Fortnite (gaming/PS controller, Fortnite sign, fortnite llama, John Jones/Jonesy) 

Frozen  (Elsa, Anna, Olaf, Snowflake)

KPop Demon Hunters – Rumi, Derpy Tiger and Soda Pop can available 

Lilo and Stitch (Stitch, Angel, Lilo, surfboard, beach ball  

Mexican fiesta (llama, mexican skull, maracas, sombrero, watermelon)  

Minecraft (creeper, TNT, Steve/minecraft character), pickaxe, Minecraft word/sign)    

Minions  

Old MacDonald’s Farmyard (barn, farmer, cow, horse, chicken, sheep, pig)  

Paddington Bear   

Paw Patrol (6x pups)   

Peppa Pig   

Pirate (pirate face, map, pirate ship, treasure chest, pirate parrot)   

Pixar Cars  

Pokemon (pikachu, pokemon ball, pokemon word/sign, bulbasaur, charmander, squirtle)  

Princess/Prince (Princess, knight, crown, princess dress, castle)  

Safari animals (tiger, zebra, lion, giraffe, monkey)  

Superheroes (batman, captain america, superman, wonder woman, hulk, spiderman, iron man)  

Teacher appreciation cookies – pencil shape with ‘best teacher ever’ stamped on, heart shape with ‘it takes a big heart to shape little minds’ stamped on, globe shape with ‘best teacher in the world’ stamped on, thank you shape with a love heart

Transport (tractor, train, rocket, plane, car, train, digger, dump truck, fire truck,excavator  

Underwater (mermaid – 2 varieties available, fish, mermaid tail, seahorse, shell, shark)  

Unicorns   

Woodland animals (squirrel, hedgehog, deer, fox, owl) 

 

INDIVIDUAL SHAPES: 

Astronaut
Axolotl  

Baby shower shapes - ‘baby’ word/sign, pram, baby bottle, teddy bear, round cookie with ‘Oh Baby’ stamp, hot air balloon, rainbow  

Bath tub/bubble bath  

Beer  

Booger on finger, from picking nose (goes with two cutters: “If you were a booger” and “I would pick you”   

Bow   

Buzz Lightyear  

Buzzy bee (two available)  

Capybara wearingara wearing birthday hat  

Caravan and palm trees   

Cassette tape    

Champagne glass  

Christmas theme – Santa, sleigh, bells, stocking, reindeer, Christmas tree, candy cane, holly, gift box,  wreath

Cocomelon  

Cookie Monster  

Croc shoe   

Darth Vader   

Diamond ring (with or without ‘bride to be’ stamped in it’   

Dog paw print  

Dogman  

Donut – heart shaped with sprinkles   

Dragon  

Easter themed cookies – bunny face, bunny in potplant, bunny in the back of old school ute truck, stained glass window with three crosses, stained glass window with one cross and love hearts, easter egg, ‘hoppy easter’ with bunny ears, bunny holding easter egg, praying hands, ‘Have a blessed Easter’ message for round cookie  

Elmo   

First lap around the track – custom message on a round cookie with a race car in the centre  

First trip around the sun – custom message on round cookie with a ‘1’ in a sun in centre  

Fishing rod  

Flags – tino rangatiratanga / Maori flag, Tonga, Samoa   

Flamingo   

Fruits – strawberries, watermelon, pineapple  

Gabby’s dollhouse – mercat, baby box  

Gaming controllers – PlayStation controller, Nintendo switch   

Ghost-Spder / Gwen Stacy  

Goose wearing bowtie  

Graduation hat/cap  

Groot   

Gymnast  

Heart  

Hello Kitty/Sanrio and friends (Hello Kitty, Kuromi, Cinnamoroll, Pochacco, My Melody)  

Hot air balloon   

Kapa haka tamariki (girl and boy kapa haka kids)   

Kirby  

Kitty cat 

KPop Demon Hunters – Rumi, Derpy Tiger and Soda Pop can available 

Labubu (two available – just the face, or full body)  

Lady with cucumbers on eyes, being pampered  

Lego head (three faces available to stamp on)  

Lollies/Candy - mini size (you get two for the price of one for this size)   

Love heart sunglasses (normal sunglasses and Barbie sunglasses also available)  

Marching boots custom stamp to stamp on round cookie   

Mario (super mario)   

Martini glass with ribbon/bow  

Mason jar with ‘thanks a bunch’ stamped – perfect with several flower cookies  

Mickey and Minnie  

Mini hearts – various shapes in mini size (you get two for the price of one for this size)  

Moana  

Monster / cheeky monster – two available   

Monster trucks (two available)  

Nerf – word/sign   

Ninja  

Ninja Turtle  

Numbers (numbers 1-9 available)  

NZ Warriors  

Old skool boom box stereo   

Other animals: gorilla, teddy bear, sloth, kitty cat, buzzy bee x2, cartoon elephant, flamingo  

Palm tree  

Pancakes stacked on a plate  

Planet with rings around it   

Poker chip (miniature cutter, can stamp number/age in middle)  

Pooh bear (pooh head, hunny pot)  

Praying hands  

Pyjamas / PJs  

R18 – boobs, penis, couple ‘cuddling’ in position  

Rainbow – two options available  

Ribbon (ca be used for pink ribbon events, or any other colour)  

Roblox (character head, roblox sign/word)  

Robot  

Rollerskate   

Scream mask (Scream the movie)  

Sending love and cookies custom stamp for round cookie  

Shark  

Shooting star  

Shopping trolley   

Shrek head   

Sleep mask  

Slippers   

Sloth  

Smiley face   

Sonic (two available – full body or just Sonic’s head)   

Spidey   

Spongebob and Patrick   

Sport balls – miniature size basketball, softball, soccer/football (also available in full size), rugby ball, netball/volleyball, tennis ball  

Square cookie with “I saw this cookie and thought fuck it that’ll do” message   

Squishmallow (unicorn squishmallow)   

Star  

Star Wars sign   

Super baby – for first birthday! Baby has a superhero mask and cape, and a ‘1’ stamped on front  

Syrup bottle for pancakes theme   

Tea pot   

Teacher appreciation cookies – pencil shape with ‘best teacher ever’ stamped on, heart shape with ‘it takes a big heart to shape little minds’ stamped on, globe shape with ‘best teacher in the world’ stamped on, thank you shape with a love heart  

Ten pin bowling (two options)  

Thank you and love heart custom shape  

Tiki  

Tools (hammer, spanner, saw)

Transformers – two shapes available (autobot, decepticon)  

Trolls’ Poppy  

Trophy   

Trout fish   

WWE sign/logo   

‘Love you to the moon and back’ custom stamp for round cookie   

​

-Updated 4 Nov 2025-